[ad3]
One Up components started a couple years ago offering 42T hop up cogs so riders could upgrade their 1 x 10, 11-36T systems to get a broad gear range on a budget. Since then it seems the whole MTB world moved to 1 X systems and the limit keeps getting pushed in terms of gearing.
One Up sent us their 50T rear cog and their Shark cage adapter for an 11-42T cassette. We installed it a few weeks ago and since have been pedaling away on it in Punta Ala to see how well it works.
Specifications
- 18T sprocket provides more even cassette progression for smoother cadence and improved shifting
- Shark Cage is compatible with M9000/M8000M7000 GS and SGS derailleurs and offers 50% more pulley offset than stock
- Uses standard freehub driver bodies (Not XD)
- 8 upshift points.
- Patented (US 9,011,282)
- Cassette progression: 11-13-15-18-21-24-28-32-37-42-50
- Sprocket Material: 7075-T6 Aluminum (50T and Cage), Nickel plated hardened steel (18T)
- Cassette range improvement: 19%
- Weight: Cassette upgrade 80g, RD upgrade 9g
- Price: €120
On the Trail
There is no doubt the 50T on the back gave us a new huge gear range that when we first went pedaling with it, we found it a bit too low with our 30T front chain-ring. We switched this out to a 32T and we felt we had found a gear ratio that worked really well for our 500 metre local climbs. The 11T on the top end was enough for some speed in the descents, and on the climbs things were easy enough with the 50T. Our setup uses 27.5″ wheels and we are moderately fit.
The key to the system working well after initial cassette setup, is the “Shark” cage. We tried the 50T without it and it was crunchy. We installed the XTR derailleur with the modified cage and shifting became Shimano smooth. The top pulley on the derailleur is moved backwards a bit and the cage also lengthens so it can take up more chain wrap. Overall the top pulley is better positioned for the chain to move into the bigger 50T gear without the B-tension screw being wound in too far. In fact we didn’t have to touch the B-tension screw, the system just worked.
We did some climbs and descents, noting that the rear derailleur behaved well on rough descents. With the longer cage we were worried about it being a bit more vulnerable to rock hits, but we have not experienced any problems so far. Shifting to lower gears with the clutch engaged worked well. We noticed that shifting into higher gears was better with the clutch disengaged. Past attempts by other “adapter” brands always failed to impress us when shifting into higher gears, after cogs wore rather quickly. We will be seeing how the One Up 50T solution works after a bit of wear, but so far so good.
As well as the lowest gear being substituted, you need to remove the 7th and 8th gear and replace them with the 18T cog, this in our experience gave a better shifting step in the middle of the block and made complete sense.
Hacking The System
There is no doubt that One Up is innovating as much as they can to help riders get bigger simpler ranges as cheaply as possible. Drive train makers don’t support these types of “hack” components, as it voids all warranties and is outside the design characteristics of what the drive train maker intended. We played around with the One Up system a bit and found a SRAM chain actually worked better than a Shimano chain with it (a tip from our local bike shop), we also found we could mix branded cassette parts as well; something that also improved shifting in different parts of the cassette, so we came up with a really hybrid system. In a sense we hacked the hacker…
Conclusion
One Up have created an innovative product. It provides extra gear range and does so for a pretty low price. Overall we would rate their solution in this case with the 50T mod as pretty good regarding performance. Although we have ridden it a lot, we’ve only been on it for a few weeks so regarding long term wear we will have to see in a few months how it is working.
The key component for the mod to work well and shift smoothly is the Shark cage. We played with a few other components as well to see what else was possible and came up with a smoothly working cassette that gave us a huge gear range that doesn’t cost a lot. (More details on our hack at a later date).
If price is a concern, when chasing big ratio ranges on your 1 x 11 system, then the 50T/18T Shark cage combo is a certainly worth trying. As always though if you do this mod don’t complain about imperfections or expect a warranty on your other drive train components.
